On Monday I gave a guest talk to Professor Rym M’Hallah’s Systems Engineering Principles class at King’s College London. We spent the hour on two recent incidents. Both are worth a look if you run a small business, because neither one started where you’d expect.
The fridges in France
Last month someone logged into the refrigeration controls at hundreds of French supermarkets and switched them to defrost overnight. Estimates go as high as 700 stores. Fridges and freezers climbed to around 50°C, food had to be thrown away, and some stores had fires.
Nobody broke in. The panels that run a store’s fridges are connected to the internet so maintenance contractors can adjust them remotely and get alerts when something goes wrong. That’s genuinely useful. It’s also a way in. A fix had been out for over a year. It just never got installed.
At the start of this month it happened again, this time across several European countries. In the Netherlands, most of the businesses hit were butcher shops and small independent grocers. So this isn’t just a problem for the big chains.
The check-in desks
Then we looked at Collins Aerospace. Last September a cyberattack took down the check-in software it supplies to airports. Heathrow, Brussels and Berlin all ended up checking passengers in by hand, with long queues and cancelled flights. None of those airports was attacked directly. They all relied on the same supplier.
The question that kept coming back
One question came up again and again in the room: why does a fridge need to be on the internet at all?
Sometimes there’s a good reason. Remote monitoring means a contractor can spot a fault before the stock is ruined. Sometimes the honest answer is that it came that way and nobody thought to switch it off.
The gaps between companies
Both cases broke in the gaps between companies. In the supermarkets, one firm made the controllers, another looked after them, and the store owned the fridges. Whose job was the update? At the airports, everything depended on a system none of them ran themselves.
Looking after those gaps is what systems engineers already do. That’s why I think security belongs in their requirements from day one. It’s much harder to add once everything’s built and running. I hope that’s what the students took away.
What this means for your business
You probably don’t run 700 stores. But you very likely have kit on the internet that you rarely think about: a card terminal, CCTV, the router your broadband provider installed, a heating controller, an online booking system. And you rely on suppliers you don’t control.
A few questions worth asking this week:
- What in my business is connected to the internet, and does it need to be?
- Who’s responsible for updating it? Me, the supplier, or a contractor? Is that written down anywhere?
- If one supplier went down tomorrow, what would stop working?
Keeping software up to date is one of the five controls in Cyber Essentials, the UK government-backed scheme. It expects high and critical security updates to be installed within 14 days. If you’d like help working through these questions for your own business, you can book a call with me.
Thank you to Rym for inviting me in and giving me an hour of her class. It was a real pleasure.
Aisha